Beyond the glow: Can a mobile flashlight ever replace the heart of the lantern?

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent comparison of the mobile phone flashlight with the lantern, the election symbol of the Rashtriya Janata Dal, during an election rally in Bihar has sparked a crucial, and deeply emotional, debate. The political jab was clear: a symbol of the past is rendered obsolete by a modern tool. Yet, this simple comparison overlooks a profound cultural truth: in India, a lantern is not merely a source of light; it is a repository of history, tradition, and hope. The question is not about brightness, but about legacy. Can the cold, instantaneous beam of a mobile phone ever replace the emotional warmth of the ancestral flame?

The modern reality is that the mobile flashlight has become the go-to tool for modern collective expression. When thousands of citizens turn on their flashlights at political rallies, concerts, or ceremonies, it is a powerful, unifying act. It symbolises solidarity, enthusiasm, and respect—a contemporary iteration of holding up lighters or candles. From honoring a veteran leader to celebrating an electoral victory, the ‘sea of stars’ effect creates an immediate, celebratory, and digital-age atmosphere. It’s a spontaneous gesture, accessible to all, and perfectly suited to the pace of the 21st century.

Advertisement

However, the lantern—and its cousin, the traditional diya (oil lamp)—draws its power from millennia of Indian culture. It is not a modern convenience but an ancient, sacred symbol woven into the very fabric of the nation’s spiritual and social life.

For generations, the lantern has been the guiding light that dispelled both literal and metaphorical darkness. Its core symbolism is profound.

Triumph over Ignorance: The light represents knowledge and enlightenment overcoming confusion and ignorance.

Victory of Good over Evil: This is the central theme of Diwali, the Festival of Lights, where the rows of lamps symbolise Lord Rama’s return and the victory of justice.

Connection to the Divine: Lighting a lamp is a sacred act of worship, believed to invite divine presence and blessings, particularly those of Goddess Lakshmi, the deity of wealth and prosperity.

Ancestral Link: Traditions like the Akash Deep (sky lamp) explicitly link the lantern’s light to guiding ancestral spirits, connecting the living to their past and inviting future prosperity.

This is the light that guided farmers home, helped children study, and illuminated countless festivals long before electricity arrived. It connects the individual not just to an event, but to their ancestors and cultural traditions.

The Prime Minister’s comparison, while politically astute in its attempt to brand an opponent as outdated, forces a consideration of what we are truly valuing. The mobile light is a tool of utility and instant gratification. It is a temporary signal of support. The lantern, on the other hand, is an emotional anchor. It carries the collective memory of survival, faith, and continuity.

Can a phone’s LED, however bright, replace the warm, flickering flame that has represented hope and resilience for ages? For the millions of Indians who have grown up with the lantern as their primary source of light, especially in rural areas, it is more than a mere object; it is a nostalgic link to a simpler life and a symbol of development yet to be fully achieved.

Ultimately, the mobile flashlight represents the future—digital, fast, and global. The lantern represents the roots—sacred, enduring, and deeply Indian. While technology will undoubtedly supplant traditional tools in daily life, it will never entirely erase the emotional attachment that centuries of symbolic meaning have forged. The mobile light will signal support at a rally, but it is the lantern’s flame that will continue to light the home fires of memory and tradition. The heart, after all, does not measure light in watts, but in wonder. END