Ravi Shastri should coach England after Ashes setback, says Monty Panesar; Questions McCullum after Ashes

Brendon McCullum’s coaching methods have come under increasing scrutiny following England’s latest Ashes setback in Australia, with the much-hyped ‘Bazball’ approach failing to deliver in the conditions it was designed to conquer. England’s hopes of regaining the Ashes faded within 11 days as Australia surged to a 3-0 lead in the five-match series.

The visitors had a chance to chase a record 435-run target in Adelaide but fell 82 runs short, once again extending their long wait for an Ashes series win in Australia. The heavy defeat has increased debate on England’s leadership group, with McCullum and captain Ben Stokes facing mounting pressure.

Advertisement

Former England spinner Monty Panesar has gone a step further, calling for a major shake-up in English cricket by backing former India head coach Ravi Shastri as McCullum’s replacement.

Speaking to journalist Ravi Bisht on his YouTube channel ‘Sports With Ravishh’ on December 23, Panesar highlighted Shastri’s proven pedigree in Australian conditions, pointing to India’s historic back-to-back Test series victories in Australia in 2018-19 and 2020-21 under his tenure.

“You have to think, who exactly knows how to beat Australia? How do you exploit their weaknesses mentally, physically and tactically? I think Ravi Shastri should become England’s next head coach,” Panesar said.

While England showed flashes of brilliance during the series, their failure to translate aggressive intent into sustained success has cast doubt on the effectiveness of the ‘Bazball’ philosophy in Australian conditions. England have not won a Test series Down Under since their famous 2010–11 triumph.

Shastri had also weighed in on England’s Ashes prospects before the series began, offering tactical advice on how the Ben Stokes-led side could compete more effectively in Australia. Speaking on SENQ Breakfast, the former India coach said:

“But in the long term, I think England will challenge. In the last two or three series here, they’ve been blown away. This time, if their fast bowlers are fully fit for the first three Test matches, they can make inroads,” Shastri had said.

England, who last won the Ashes in 2015 and have not secured a Test victory in Australia since 2011, have made two changes to their XI for the Boxing Day Test in Melbourne.

With criticism of McCullum’s methods growing and Shastri’s Australia expertise once again in focus, the former India coach has emerged as a central figure in discussions around England’s future direction.