Nepal: can a film director draft constitutional amendments? PM Balen Shah faces backlash for controversial appointment

Image Source: Facebook


Nepal’s Prime Minister Balendra (Balen) Shah has tasked his political advisor Asim Shah with preparing a discussion paper on constitutional amendments. The decision, made during a cabinet meeting on Monday, has sparked questions about whether someone without a legal or constitutional background should lead such a critical initiative.

Asim Shah became a proportional representative member of parliament in 2022 from the Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP). Before entering politics, he worked as a film director and is known for movies like ‘Karkash’. The song “Kutmā Kutu” from Dui Rupaiya remains popular on YouTube.

Also Read: Balen Shah government proposes to ban political and student unions; experts warn democracy at risk

Historical context of constitutional review in Nepal

Nepal’s constitution envisions a review of commissions and structural provisions every ten years. In 2024, when the Nepali Congress and CPN-UML formed the government, both parties had agreed to evaluate the strengths, weaknesses, and complexities of the constitution, and propose amendments and related legislation to ensure political stability.

During elections, the RSP’s manifesto included a promise to initiate debates on constitutional amendments.

The party has consistently advocated changing the governance system to support a directly elected executive prime minister.

Also Read: Age reset in government: Balen Shah leads cabinet where 10 of 15 ministers are under 40 and the oldest is 51

Process and scope

Before assigning responsibilities, PM Shah reportedly consulted Asim. The task force will include legal secretaries from the Prime Minister’s Office, define its scope, send letters to all political parties, and hold consultations with experts before drafting the discussion paper.

Importantly, the task force will not itself amend constitution. Its mandate is to gather views and draft discussion document focused on strengthening electoral systems and federal structures, ensuring widespread consultation before any amendments.

Also Read: Two statements, one policy mess: Nepal’s new Education Minister faces backlash over contradictory ban on coaching classes