It took more than a decade, a long legal wait, and one comedy punchline that refused to fade away. But now, the curtain has finally dropped on a case. In a fresh and clear ruling, the Bombay High Court has erased a 2010 FIR against Shekhar Suman and Bharti Singh.
Back in November 2010, an episode of the popular comedy show ‘Comedy Circus Ka Jadoo’ aired on Sony Entertainment Television. But one line from that episode did not land the same way for everyone.
Also Read: In ‘Still Alive’, Samay Raina addresses Latent backlash and ‘victimhood’, but avoids questions on misogynistic and incel-style comedy
A complaint was filed by a man named Mohd. Imran Dadani Rasabi. He claimed that certain words used in the show, “Ya Allah! Rasgulla! Dahi Bhalla!”, had hurt the religious sentiments of members of the Muslim community.
Soon after, the complaint reached the Pydhonie Police Station. Based on this, an FIR was registered under Section 295-A of the Indian Penal Code, along with Section 34, which deals with shared criminal intent.
What the law actually says
As the case moved forward, the spotlight shifted from the stage to the law books. Section 295-A deals with deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings.
The court carefully examined whether that key requirement was present.
In its order dated April 29, the Bombay High Court made it clear: for a case under Section 295-A to stand, there must be clear proof of intention to insult religion.
The judges noted that the expressions used in the show were part of a scripted comedy performance. There was no sign that the actors were trying to hurt anyone’s beliefs.
The court also pointed out something very basic but important, terms like “rasgulla” and “dahi bhalla” are common food items. They do not carry any religious meaning on their own.
In short, the legal test of “deliberate and malicious intention” was simply not met.